1 star out of 5
Director Wally Pfister pfists the moviegoing public with this boring, incomprehensible piece of garbage. I knew there was trouble in the opening seconds when, in a movie with Morgan Freeman in the cast, somebody else was doing voiceover narration. (Don’t worry, don’t worry, about a half hour in, ol’ Morgan gets to read a letter off-screen.) Let’s also give some blame to Christopher Nolan (one of the executive producers) who really likes overly complicated horseshit. (See Inception. On second thought, don’t.)
But really, the lion’s share of blame must go to Johnny Depp. I would not have gone to see this movie if he was not the lead actor. I tend to trust Johnny Depp. He has cool friends: Keith Richards, Tom Waits, Tim Burton, the late Hunter S. Thompson. Couldn’t he have asked one of them—ok, Hunter, you’re off the hook—for their opinion on the script? Or maybe after The Lone Ranger, his inner circle has basically said “You’re on your own.”
Depp is too handsome to be playing some artificial-intelligence super genius. (He is a bit puffy, but I’m not sure that was for the role.) Rebecca Hall, as the wife, is too beautiful to be his scientific partner; she has the look of a gorgeous French actress bravely doing an American accent. (Turns out she’s actually British, do, points off.)
The movie doesn’t start out terrible, but at no point is it actually good. For the first half, it kind of muddles along, with too much talking, surprisingly slow pacing, and some not-at-all original debating about technology: whether it is, you know, good or bad. There are anti-tech terrorists led by, well, I thought it was Rooney Mara but because this is a shitty movie we only get Kate Mara. And then Johnny Depp gets turned into an operating system but there’s no Joaquin Phoenix to fall in love with him. As we just learned from Scarlett Johannson in Under the Skin, if you’re artificial intelligence you have to say aloud a list of every English word to show that you’re learning, so we get that tedious scene here too.
In the back half, the movie goes from watchably mediocre into something increasingly stupider and stupider, finally transcending to a truly higher level of stupidity. It’s 2001 and Elysium and Source Code (they even say the words “source code” a few times) and it is absolute junk. Johnny should’ve kicked this one to Richard Grieco.
Jack Silbert, curator